visualgui

Thanh Lam – Nay Em Co Nho

Thanh Lam and Le Minh Son, once again, reinvigorated Trinh Cong Son’s pop standards on Nay Em Co Nho, their third studio collaboration. By weaving eastern instruments (three-stringed lute, sixteen-stringed zither and flute) into the western (piano, guitar, violin, viola, and cello), Le Minh Son produced ingenious semi-classic harmonies. The east-meets-west musical palette gives Thanh Lam plenty of colors and room to paint Trinh’s lyrical images.

Like most Vietnamese singers (and listeners), Thanh Lam loves and respects Trinh’s works. Even though she approaches his materials with her own passion, especially on the voluptuous rendition of “Phoi Pha,” she never fails to embrace his melodies, caress his verses, and nurture his rhymes. Even on the weird recovering of “Mot Coi Di Ve,” she coarsens and punctuates in strange places, but Trinh’s aesthetics never leave the canvas. At first, I preferred the old jazz standard version, which she gave an indelible presentation on the classic Ru Doi Di Nhe, over the new eccentric classical-jazz arrangement by pianist Tran Manh Hung; however, I am more convinced after several spins. The oddness becomes natural, and that’s the way the album grows: slowly but surely.

Trinh’s signature pieces are not new to us, but Thanh Lam’s deliveries are. Like the way she flows in and out of the staccato violin on “Lang Le Noi Nay” is breathtaking. On “Nay Em Co Nho,” she maneuvers skillfully around the sonorous violin and piano accents giving the title track a soulful performance. Accompanied by Le Minh Son’s nimble-fingered guitar, Thanh Lam gives “Bien Nho” a gorgeous reminiscent of Khanh Ly and Trinh Cong Son, despite the differences in styles. Elsewhere, the clear-pitched flute not only balances her slightly gruff voice, but also assists her to paint incomparable images of Saigon, such as sunrises, rainfalls, streetlights, green tamarind leafs and familiar bricks, on the nostalgic “Em Con Nho Hay Em Da Quen.”

Last year, Thanh Lam and Le Minh Son shocked us with the groundbreaking Ru Mai Ngan Nam. If the sequel does not strike our chords, it is because we are used to its predecessor. In any rate, Nay Em Co Nho is unquestionably an expansive artistic vision from an accomplished vocalist and a talented producer.

Thanks Thao Suong for the album.

14 Comments

  1. Damn, you’ve got the album already? I’m still waiting for mine. Should be here between now and saturday.

    Comment by TTBlue — 21 July 2005 @ 12:54 pm
  2. this album is two thumbs up!

    Comment by Anonymous — 22 July 2005 @ 12:17 am
  3. I’ve got this CD. Thanh Lam’s voice is still strong and warm. I like the song ” Em con nho hay em da quen”. This song make me miss Saigon so much. I am looking forward to hearing from ” Em va dem”

    Comment by Dien Duong — 24 July 2005 @ 10:38 am
  4. Although Thanh Lam is a very good singer but I think it is time to stop butchering Trinh Cong Son’s song collection. What I am talking about is the trend of using or singing TCS’s song to minimized the critics of a new release CD got to stop. Did you hear what Lam did on the first one with Le Minh Son…oh my god they murder TCS’s songs.
    Think the next step and nature progression for Trinh’s collection is to have foreign musicians to know and realize the genius behind TCS and let them (the foreign musicians or singer) have their take on it.

    other than that…to the VNese singers, do something new would you.

    again IMHO, other’s may vary.

    Comment by Blfat — 26 July 2005 @ 10:24 am
  5. Blfat, you should do a little search on Don’s site and found that he raved the previous album. As for your opinion of Thanh Lam & Le Minh Son murdered/butchered TCS’s works, that’s open for interpretation. For those whom love the traditional ways of performing it, Ru Mai Ngan Nam and Nay Em Co Nho would considered as a catastrophe. For the more liberal listeners, it’s a fresh attempt on the classics. Yes, there are some faults but overall, it’s an exhilarating experience. The music is top notch (all recorded with accoustic instruments) and the interpretation is well done.

    I personally think her previous album is better than this one eventhough (according to Le Minh Son) it took only one week to produce. But that’s because I only listen through it once. I’ve been through Ru Mai Ngan Nam numerous times, so it’s not quite far comparison.

    On a lighter note, if you’re interested in TCS’s work by foreign musicians, check out Makoto Kubota’s album … Hotel Vietnam. He had one TCS’s song, Rung Xua Da Khep on the album and it sounds (for a lack of a better word) extraordinary. The music and the voice is perfectly matched and it’s near live performance level. But I’ve to warn you though, it’s not cheap. I bought it for $28 plus s/h on amazon.

    Comment by TTBlue — 26 July 2005 @ 5:17 pm
  6. Le Minh Son incorporate more instruments on Nay Em Co Nho, especially the traditional ones, but I still like the first one better because of the piano solos and Thanh Lam singings were more dramatic. Other than “Mot Coi Di Ve” and “Phoi Pha,” the rest on the latter album is much softer.

    Comment by donny — 26 July 2005 @ 5:39 pm
  7. Can you believe this? Phuong Thanh had just released a TCS’s album entitled “Thuong Mot Nguoi.” I mean, really… of all the singers… can Phuong Thanh muster TCS’s songs? I’m reluctant to buy the album just because the last time I heard Dam Vinh Hung interpretation of TCS, I had almost puke. No offense to fan of DVH, but that album just blows.

    Comment by TTBlue — 26 July 2005 @ 7:17 pm
  8. Blfat, Ru Mai Ngan Nam was voted as the NUMBER ONE CD in Vietnam in 2004. If it was butchering TCS music, it wouldn’t get the votes!

    Comment by Anonymous — 26 July 2005 @ 7:45 pm
  9. God bless Trinh’s music. It’s like if you’re Vietnamese singer, you have to have a Trinh’s album. I am still curious how Chanh gonna pull this off.

    Comment by donny — 27 July 2005 @ 3:05 pm
  10. give TCS a rest! His words may be great and all but musically his songs are b o r i n g

    Comment by jeff — 28 July 2005 @ 9:23 pm
  11. jeff… TCS is like an American version of Bob Dylan. One of the greatest song writer ever lived in VN. And that’s something to be proud of. If you head over to giaidieu.net and check out their forum, TCS is like a religion to some of the folks over there. People read too much into TCS music sometime… gives it almost like a mythical power. Deep, powerful, emotional, etc.. etc.. etc.

    I personally admired all of TCS works. To see that many singers just out right abuse the name TCS to get some fame is just lame.

    Comment by TTBlue — 29 July 2005 @ 1:55 am
  12. A little
    excerpt

    from a Pham Duy interview:

    Interviewer: Theo ông, từ trước tới nay ai hát nhạc của ông hay nhất?

    PD: Xưa thì có Thái Thanh, Duy Quang, nay thì có Thái Hiền, và tôi cũng thích Thanh Lam nữa.

    Comment by joseph — 29 July 2005 @ 2:58 pm
  13. Hu+`m, I never expect someday TCS’s songs can be performed by Phuong Thanh:-(( Her voice and her style are not suitable to perform TCS’s. It’s not so surprising that many singers have taken advantage of Trinh’s songs to get famous:-(((

    Comment by Dung Nguyen — 5 August 2005 @ 4:12 pm
  14. TL sang well in the song Em hay ngu di. But i prefer Hong Nhung cover a bit more. I also like Khanh Ha in Nay em co Nho, Cam Van cover of Phoi pha and mot coi di ve. The music arrangement is excellent in this cd…I think i prefer to listen to the music… her em con nho hay em da quen is excellent though. And I like Thanh Lam singing in her own style. We can’t expect TL to sing like Khanh Ly or Hong Nhung or any other singers because what would be the point of singing the same? She would be an average singer then… But Thanh lam is a diva and she has her own style and i’m interested in what her next project will bring out…

    Comment by Lam Dien — 27 August 2005 @ 10:54 am