visualgui

Xuan Khoi – Chieu Mot Minh Qua Pho

Xuan Khoi sounds so much like Tuan Ngoc, only sleepier. In fact, Tuan Ngoc is all over his new album, Chieu Mot Minh Qua Pho. As soon as Xuan Khoi begins to sing the first bar on the opening track, Tu Cong Phung’s “Tren Thang Ngay Da Qua,” you can immediately recognize the phrasing. Even the music is arranged in Duy Cuong’s Latin flavor.

Like many of Tuan Ngoc’s followers, Xuan Khoi isn’t capable of reaching the upper register with ease, a skill that sets Tuan Ngoc apart from his imitators. Tuan Ngoc’s influence is even more transparent on Tu Cong Phung’s “Tinh Tu Mua Xuan.” Not only his phrasing, but his flow and his vibrato come straight from Tuan Ngoc’s classic rendition. The difference is that Xuan Khoi gets shaky on the long notes and he lacks the romance and authority Tuan Ngoc brought to the tune. Obviously Duy Cuong’s semi-classical orchestration is unmatchable.

The whole time I am listening to Xuan Khoi, yet all I could think about is Tuan Ngoc. From Pham Duy’s “Tinh Cam” to Ngo Thuy Mien’s “Ao Lua Ha Dong” to Nguyen Trung Cang’s “Bang Khuan Chieu Noi Chu,” Xuan Khoi simply can’t escape Tuan Ngoc’s shadow. Both Xuan Khoi and I have one thing in common: we spend way too much time with the musician’s musician. My suggestion to Xuan Khoi is to stop listening to Tuan Ngoc, stay away from Tuan Ngoc’s repertoire, and don’t even think about covering Ngo Thuy Mien’s “Rieng Mot Goc Troi.”

12 Comments

  1. You can say the same things about the likes of Quang Dung, Nguyen Khang, and countless other mini/semi-Tuan Ngoc’s of the world. The only one sincere enough to admit it was Nguyen Khang.
    Regarding Rieng Mot Goc Troi, there is a reason why TN vehemently refused to let it be synonymous with his name, because it wasn’t. What really made TN was the Giot Le Cho Ngan Sau album, a masterpiece still unsurpassed by the man himself ‘til this day. Rieng Mot Goc Troi was a jumble of nonsensical pretty words that were put in the song just because they sounded romantic, a rampant trait in many of Ngo Thuy Mien’s tunes. Just because something sounds good doesn’t mean it’s worth anything

    Comment by The float abides! — 8 March 2010 @ 11:05 am
  2. I totally concurred, Giot Le Cho Ngan Sau remains one of my favorite Vietnamese albums til this day. I can listen to the whole record over and over again.

    Yes, “Rieng Mot Goc Troi” is a pretty tune and when you say that song, it has Tuan Ngoc’s name tagged to it. Even a non-Tuan Ngoc fan can recognize it.

    Comment by donny — 8 March 2010 @ 2:50 pm
  3. Donny, you could be more serious with song titles. ;)

    Comment by sadvalley — 8 March 2010 @ 10:13 pm
  4. sadvalley, not sure what you mean.

    Float, actually there are more classic albums from Tuan Ngoc than just “Giot Le Cho Ngan Sau.” Both “Dem Thay Ta La Thac Do” (Trinh Cong Son’s songbook) and “Du Nghin Nam Qua Di” (Dang Khanh’s songbook) are masterpieces in its own rights.

    Comment by donny — 9 March 2010 @ 2:45 pm
  5. Dear Donny:

    Trên Tháng Ngày Đã Qua & Bâng Khuâng Chiều Nội Trú là 2 tên chính xác của 2 bài hát trong review của bạn!

    Chúc Donny vui!

    Comment by Phạm Thiên Nhiên — 9 March 2010 @ 5:01 pm
  6. Thanks PTN. This is what happen when you blog half asleep.

    Comment by donny — 9 March 2010 @ 5:06 pm
  7. “Bang Khuan Chieu Noi Tru” >> still wrong. ;)

    Comment by sadvalley — 9 March 2010 @ 8:24 pm
  8. Aww.. looks like Tuan Ngoc is da man…..

    Comment by Thu Hoai — 9 March 2010 @ 10:10 pm
  9. da man? hehe……as in cruel?

    Comment by lam dien — 10 March 2010 @ 7:15 pm
  10. Still manly and sexy old man :)

    Comment by Thu Hoai — 11 March 2010 @ 11:34 pm
  11. “da man”
    dã man: cruel
    the man: still manly and sexy old man

    Comment by sadvalley — 12 March 2010 @ 12:07 am
  12. Yes “the man ” he is !

    Comment by Thu Hoai — 12 March 2010 @ 7:54 pm